Biscuit came home from the county shelter at two years old, sixty-five pounds of Labrador mix and opinions. Most of those opinions were about the leash. He pulled, I followed, and neither of us enjoyed the walk much.
That was a year ago. He is three now, and our walks are quieter. Not perfect, and I will not tell you otherwise. What changed was not a special collar or a louder voice. It was carrying the right treat in my pocket and being willing to use it forty times a day.
The right treat turned out to be Blue Buffalo Bits, the chicken recipe, in the nineteen ounce bag. June picked it up because it fit on the shelf and because the first ingredient listed is real chicken, and she is the one in this house who reads labels.
I am not a trainer. I spent twenty-eight years walking a mail route here in Sedalia, Missouri, which means I have met every kind of dog there is through a screen door. That is not the same as knowing how to teach one. What I know is what worked in my own kitchen and on my own sidewalk.
Here is the problem I kept running into. Biscuit will work for food, but not all food is worth working for. Plain kibble got a polite sniff and nothing else. The big crunchy biscuits were a production, three bites minimum, and by the time he finished chewing the moment had passed and his attention had left for whatever the neighbor's cat was doing.
Blue Buffalo Bits are soft and moist, and small enough that a dog can take one and look right back at you for the next, which is the whole point when you are trying to mark a behavior inside of a second. Corn free, soy free, wheat free, and soft enough that I can break one in half for the easy stuff.
A treat that takes three bites to finish is not a reward. It is a snack break, and the training stops while it happens.
Small, soft, and quick enough to keep up with a dog that is paying attention
I keep a handful in my jacket pocket and the bag on the shelf by the door. Chicken first, soft enough to break, and fast enough to actually land on the behavior you are rewarding.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →The first thing we worked on was not pulling. It was coming when called, because that one scared me. Biscuit had no recall at all at first. In the fenced backyard I would say his name, wait half a beat, and reward the second he turned his head. Ten repetitions, three times a day, four minutes total. The soft treat made that possible. A crunchy biscuit would have turned it into a twenty minute project and I would have quit by Wednesday.
Leash manners came next, and slower. I carried a treat in my left hand at my thigh and stopped dead every time the leash went tight. When he looked back at me, he got one. Some blocks we covered fifty feet in ten minutes. That is not a failure, that is the work. A dog getting paid for the right behavior does not need to be corrected half as often, and I have the shoulder to prove it.
The jumping on guests took the longest. I keep a small dish of Blue Buffalo Bits by the front door now. When the bell rings, Biscuit gets sent to his bed, and the bed pays. He still gets excited. He just gets excited in one place, which is all I ever wanted out of that deal.
A word on amounts, because nobody told me this and I learned it the slow way. These are treats, not dinner. I cut his kibble back a little on days when training is heavy and I do not free-pour from the bag. Read the label, measure like you mean it, and keep the bag sealed on the shelf. One nineteen ounce bag has carried us through about six weeks of daily use.
What Bits did not fix: squirrels. Also the mail truck, which is a little embarrassing given my career. There is no treat on earth that will hold a dog's attention when a squirrel breaks cover, and I would not trust anybody who tells you otherwise. What the treats did was make the boring repetitions easy enough that we actually did them, and that is the only reason any of this worked.
The formula includes DHA, an omega-3 that supports cognitive development, plus omega 3 and 6 fatty acids from flaxseed for skin and coat. I cannot see any of that in a three year old dog on a Tuesday afternoon. What I can see is that he is eager to work and his coat looks better than it did last spring, which June credits to the treats and I credit to the treats and the brushing.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
I would tell you the gear matters less than the timing. A treat that arrives two seconds late teaches nothing but confusion. The reason Blue Buffalo Bits ended up being the thing I buy now is not that they are fancy. It is that they are small, soft enough to break, quick enough to swallow, and my dog will work for them in the rain when he will not work for a carrot.
I would tell you to pick one behavior, work it for four minutes, and quit while he still wants more. I would tell you that a rescue dog with a year of bad habits is not a lost cause, and that a sixty-one year old man with a bad knee can still teach recall in a fenced yard. And I would tell you to buy the treat your dog actually wants, then use the whole bag.
The bag that lives on the shelf by my door
One dog, one leash, four minute sessions, and a soft chicken treat that keeps up. If you are starting from the same place we were, start here.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →